Thursday, September 06, 2007
It was the worst of times, it was the worst of times
From Brian’s list, the obvious choice is Chrysalis, because it’s a French sci-fi thriller and I’m deeply suspicious of this combination genre, as I suspect it’s going to take itself far too seriously. Despite the presence of the ever luminous Juliette Binoche, sporting the blond locks that I spied when she passed within a few feet of me last year, je pense Le Voyage du Ballon Rouge va etre un voyage très ennuyeux pour m. Derek. Have a sneaking suspicion that Sarah will dislike the one I just got her yesterday ‘Silent Resident’ because it will get be too sci-fi and not enough thriller and that Da…I mean…festival co-director #3 will find himself deeply confused about which way to go regarding XXY. My biggest question mark is ‘A Gentle Breeze in the Village’, which my parents are seeing with me. It has the potential to be either too saccharine-y, too slow, or a lethal combination of both.
Back to celebs, I have a feeling that I’m most likely to bump (that’s with a b not an h, Bri, honestly…) into Rachel McAdams on my way out of Married Life as I frantically try to make Mad Detective on time. I see myself quickly explaining to her that I’d love to stay for Q & A but that Johnnie To beckons. She’s cool w/ it but Ryan Gosling gives me dirty looks and the two of us end up starting a massive brawl later that evening in the lobby of the Four Seasons Hotel. I scramble out a side door, ducking and narrowing avoiding a punch from Jodie Foster that inadvertently lands on Woody Allen (who consequently hightails it back to Manhattan, vowing never to return to TO), and look up to see Keira K staring down at me. She asks me where she can find really good falafel so we cab it to the Annex and….okay…NOW I’m getting silly.
Another question, given the glowing reviews of the Coen Brothers flick, are we bound to be disappointed? Even though it wasn’t among my initial picks, it’s now the film that I’m most looking forward to seeing. Hope that isn't the case. Happy film going, all!
UPDATE: We're number 1! Or possibly 2!
Interesting article in the Star today. The last paragraph illustrates why Piers is Da Man: articulate, gracious when it comes to describing competitors, but with a balsy certitude in stating, simply that Toronto is THE fall festival. You, Mr. Handling, rock!
Celebrities I'd like to bump into (is that a euphimism?).....let me mull on that. OK, how about Laura Linney? She's my age, is great in almost every flic she's in, reasonably well fed, and darned attractive.
The game I like to play at this point is, to guess which film will be the best and the worst from among my picks. I'm thinking that Silent Resident may be the best, based on the plot summary, the simple picture, and the fact that it's German, and not French. The one with the greatest potential for failure is clearly Man From London, the review of which proclaims its mood of a "vacuum in which no joy may enter", and celebrates "long periods of silence and stasis". The dark horse is The Banishment, whose director last film won the Golden Lion in Venice in 2003...mind you, it's a relationship film that runs 2 1/2 hours.
Wednesday, September 05, 2007
Goodbye skinny ebert
So in honour of Piers Handling and his arch nemesis Noah Cowan I am now "festival co-director #3"
Nice to meet all of you (again)
So Tired, Tired of Waiting....
couldn't resist a visit to the online box office this morning. added 'King of the Hill' on Friday September 14th at 9:15pm to my list and 'Silent Resident' on Thursday September 13th to Sarah's list. $20/per ticket w/ a $4.75 handling fee per order is not bad, at least relative to what they are charging for VSR and Gala tix.
still two days till my first film so i'll pose another question to the group:
are there any celebrities you'd like to bump into this week?
i'm hoping keira knightley will ask me to take her out for a proper meal or at the very least that she will flirt with me shamelessly. since i'm not seeing 'atonement', i'm guessing the chances of this happening are quite remote. if i were seeing 'atonement', my chances would be...well...quite remote. still, she's very pretty, albeit slim, which i think is my point.
Tuesday, September 04, 2007
Daniel's Picks
Barcelona (A Map) - Sept 9
Lars & The Real Girl - Sept 10
XXY - Sept 13
Son of Rambow - Sept 14
Sarah's Picks
Nothing is Private - Saturday September 8
A Thousand Years of Good Prayers and Princess of Nebraska - Sunday September 9
No Country For Old Men - Monday September 10
The Past - Wednesday September 12
And Along Come Tourists - Wednesday September 12
Silent Resident -Thursday 13th
Chaotic Ana - Friday September 14
Shadows - Saturday September 15
Kyle's List
Friday September 7th - The Man from London
Saturday September 8th - Happiness
Sunday September 9th - La Zona
Thursday September 13th - A Gentle Breeze in the Village
Saturday September 15th - Shadows
Very odd that I don't have any French films this year. Guess my first review will be here on either Friday night or Saturday morning. Until then, you can amuse yourselves looking at trailers at the TIFF screening room site.
Friday, August 31, 2007
skinny ebert: teacher's pet
I haven't looked at the other posts - so forgive me if I've snagged a few of your picks
CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS, THE ENIGMA: a couple spend their vacation trying to prove that Colombus was Portugese and not Italian. Oh ya, and the director is 98 years old. AND it meets Kyle's Portugese criteria
DR. PLONK: "a tribute to silent film, filmed on expired black & white film with a hand-cranked camera". I think it would be fun to bring your ipod and create your own soundtrack. Not sure how to remedy the expired film though
DEATH IN THE LAND OF ENCARTOS: 540 minutes long......if I didn't have to wash my hair....
YOU, THE LIVING: "a plot synopsis is impossible..." I'd say a viewing is impossible as well.
MISTER LONELY: a Michael Jackson impersonator, nuns throwing themselves from a plane and the creator of Julien Donkey Boy. Guess I'm getting my Harmony Korine fix after all.
LOVE SONGS: a French musical - I just can't do it
NIGHTWATCHING: a movie based on a Rembrandt painting??!! Wasn't the DaVinci Code bad enough?
FOREVER NEVER ANYWHERE: four men are trapped in a car after an accident. Not recommended for those who like anything to happen in their movies
SURFWISE - a documentary abour a whole family of surfers. Like wow! That's incredible!
DAINIPPONJIN - the protagonist is "transformed into a stocky giant several storeys high, sporting tight purple briefs, tattoos and an Eraserhead-style hairdo". There's a reason this one is playing at midnight
5 queasy pieces
2. Bad enough they let nonagenarians into the festival but Wayne Wang gets 2 films. I guess his troika of "Maid in Manhattan", "Because of Winn-Dixie" and "Last Holiday" earned him those two coveted spots.
3. Is Gary Burns at the festival?
4. "The Jane Austen Book Club". Perhaps my favourite author. Can we leave her alone now.
5. Speaking of books, "The Stone Angel". Was there a more excruciating fortnight in my life than the 2 weeks in grade 10 we spent with Mr. Thwaites toiling through this novel.
films you don't want to see
generally speaking, though i love their cuisine and wine respectively, the films of thailand and portugal tend to suck the big one so those are maybe a good places to start. visions and vanguard should offer some ripe pickings as well. see y'all monday.
Box 66 of 75
brian, since you're in just as bad/worse shape as me, perhaps we can make plans to meet up early and one of us can get a spot in the resub line. derek, daniel, hope you fared better.
tricky times these fest days be
Thursday, August 30, 2007
Kyle et al, HELP! I need a lesson on using the book to fill out my order. Are we supposed to highlight using two colours (one for first and one for second choice) the way we did a few years ago? Please drop me a line at home or post an explanation tomorrow morning if you get this message. Merci.
The real winner of the Parker Posey Award is....
Here's the longlist, with first pic/second pic:
Young People Fucking/Jar City - Thursday night
The Man From London/need to find a second pick - Friday night 6ish
Control/Secret Sunshine - Friday 9ish
The Edge of Heaven/need to find a second pick - Saturday 4ish
Nothing is Private/King of the Hill - evening, possibly taking my parents to it
Nightwatching/La Zona or The World Unseen - Sunday late aft
M/The Voyeurs - Monday evening
Unsure of:
Deficit
Margot at the Wedding
Open to suggestions/comments of the "What the *#$%& are you thinking?" or "I highly recommend you choose...." variety.
Harmony Korine
I continue to be amazed that the festival directors are actually able to write coherent synopses of his films.
Wednesday, August 29, 2007
question
Tuesday, August 28, 2007
2007 Film Festival/Festiblog Underway
After a relatively rapidfire 45-minute skimming of its contents, some initial thoughts and questions:
-The cover is pretty boring (expect similarly breathtaking analyses here in days to come).
-Best film title has to be "Young People Fucking", with an honourable mention going to "Run Fat Boy Run". Still don't think that either holds a torch to the Best Film Fest title of all time: "Virgin Stripped Bare By Her Bachelors"
-Most contradictory or just pretentious film title goes to "A Jihad for Love" and "My Brother is an Only Child"
-Most incongruous French/English title translation: Ne Touchez Pas La Hache/The Dutchess of Langeais. Runner-up: Dans La Vie/Two Ladies
-Looks like it's Ellen Page vs. Evan Rachel Wood for the coveted Parker Posey Award, awarded each year to the young female actress who seemingly appears in every other film at the fest
-Do I see the documentary "Joy Division" or the biopic "Control", based on the Deborah Curtis book "Touching From a Distance", which I enjoyed reading a few years back? Or should I just re-rent "24 Hour Party People" and skip to the part where the drummer sits on the roof of his apartment and bangs out the opening to 'She's Lost Control'?
-How is it possible that Renee Harlin is still allowed to make films? I realize I ask this question almost every year (sometimes substituting the name "Abel Ferrara") but man....
Overall, the quality of films seem really strong. It's going to be difficult to narrowing down my choices to 10.
Hoping to get a solid hour or two with the book tonight. Think I've already identified a handful that look interesting including "M", "The Man from London", "My Kid Could Paint That", "Nightwatching", and "Deficit". If there are any flaws in these choices, I invite you to unleash your sardonnic wrath upon me.
Similarly, please do share/post your long lists as I won't be able to attend the usual Thursday evening last minute picking party, due to an unforeseen change to my schedule. Happy reading!
Monday, September 18, 2006
L'intouchable
The film is shot, loosely, half in Paris and half in Delhi. For me, and I'm pretty sure this was Jacquot's intention, it really came to life when we hit the streets of Delhi. There was a "Sun Also Rises"-like existenstialism to this; whereby the search for Jeanne's identity drove a more profound and meaningful experience. The filming in India felt intensely real; the arrival at the airport, the subseqent street and public transit scenes, and the Ganges itself (particularly the footage of the burial rituals) were fantastic.
The problem I found was that the plot, which relied on the motivation of Jeanne to understand her life better, didn't feel believable. I never really got why going to the Ganges to meet the man who unknowingly impregnated her mother would make everything fall into place for her. And ultimately, she comes to the same empty realization - the meeting of the father never really occurs, she has spent all of her energy on a confused search (mistaken identity - she meets his brother), and basically no longer needs to understand more. The film ends abruptly and anti-climatically, and while this is no doubt the message that Jacquot wanted to convey - like, life is complex and its journey can change us in different ways than we expect - it makes for an unsatisfying, and what feels like an under-written (certainly underfilmed, as it all resolves in about three minutes) conclusion.
Sunday, September 17, 2006
TIFF Awards
Saturday, September 16, 2006
rotten tomatoes
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/features/special/2006/toronto_film_festival/
Friday, September 15, 2006
The volunteer love gets quieter with each screening...
If you've done your films, perhaps you can rank the ones you've seen, in whatever order you see fit, with any comments about the festival this year in general.
2 more to go tomorrow and then sadly, it's done.
Thursday, September 14, 2006
Nue Propriete (Private Property)
The movie follows the divorced mother of twin boys. She wants to sell their house so she can open a B&B with her new lover. The twins, of course, oppose. We are subjected to various scenes of conflict - mainly involving boring conversations around the dinner table. The director later stated that he relied heavily on the dinner table to illustrate the mother feeding the "monsters" she has created. MONSTERS??!!! This guy should come to dinner at my house. If he saw the twins as monsters he'd see my family as the direct descendents of Satan. The movie comes to a predictable violent climax that really is not so violent.
You may be reaching the conclusion that I just can't appreciate subtlety. You might have a point. Unfortunately for you, this is about my opinion. My opinion is that this was a plodding movie that never really went anywhere. The Festival program GROSSLY oversold this movie by describing it as the film "with some of the best acting in the festival" (Noah Cowan - you would have LOVED my performance as Pony Boy in high school). I never felt like I got to know any of the characters in any depth. I felt the twins were horribly miscast and were far too old to be playing the age you were supposed to believe they were (they bathed together, their mother bathed in front of them, they double-rided (rode?) through the fields on their motorbike, they talked about girls while playing ping pong, they played video games). I suppose Isabelle Huppert's turn as the keeper of the monsters was OK - but one performance does not a movie make.
You'd have more fun spending 2 hours French kissing.
The Hottest State
There are two things I would change. I think the movie should be half an hour shorter. At two hours it was a little long and some scenes could be lost without harming the story line or the feel of the movie.
Also, Ethan Hawk seemed too young to play William's dad in the Texas scene of the movie. If the writter/ director felt he absolutley must have a role in his own movie he should have had the makeup people age him a little more than they did. Perhaps he is old enough to be the father of a man in his early 20's but he doesn't look it. Ethan Hawk is a solid actor it was just his apperance that didn't fit.
I would recommend this movie.
Wednesday, September 13, 2006
adaptations.....
A few of my faves are "The Last Tycoon", Elia Kazan's 1975 movie of Fitzgerald's last, unfinished novel, starring DeNiro in a very unusual performance for him (a movie which, incidentally, I am somewhat unique in appreciating). Two more mainstream faves of mine are Apocalypse Now and The French Liuetenant's Woman, in both cases great and seemingly unfilmable books turned upside down and successfully re-invented as movies.
Reprise
And while I didn't recognize the JD song Kyle, never having been as big a fan, the Independence Day scene in question is imprinted on my brain as well.
Yours, not over-selling.....
Woman on the Beach
This is, I believe, my first Korean feature (though I'm getting old and I sometimes forget things), so as I watched I found myself wondering about the the current evolutionary state of the film industry in Korea. Why? Well, Woman on the Beach is almost impossibly naive in a number of ways (I'm thinking cinematography, acting, dialogue), and so the two options that began to form in my mind were that (1) this was all done very deliberately, and referentially in some really cool way - I don't know, to mimic the renewed simplicity of the 1960's French New Wave directors? - or (2) they just make films that look and feel like this in S. Korea.
Particularly after Director Hong Sang-soo was intro'd at the start as perhaps the pre-eminent director in South Korea, I couldn't (and can't) be sure. Taken at face value, Woman on the Beach, which deals in a mix of comedy and drama with a 40-something film director's (I kid you not, Cesc Gay) obsession with his buddy's girflriend, and in a (Hitchcockian?) twist in his conviction that a quite different-looking woman bears a striking resemblance, qualifies as mild and quirky entertainment. It took me ten minutes to get over the fact that it felt like it was made by high school students, and then I bought into it (due I suppose to a plot thread that worked, and a strong performance by the lead woman - Ko Hyeon-geong), until the third act, which dragged on and on (WOTB clocked in at a mind-numbing 128 minutes) and ended needlessly enigmatically. Needless, because at that point the fate of the central relationship was known (sorry, it didn't work out), and frankly, we all just wanted to go for a beer. Or a coffee. Or a walk.
Interestingly, Giovanni Fulvi, in his review in the TIFF guide, described the script as "air-tight". Giovanni, I'll be watching out for you.
Fiction
I won't bother with much in the way of plot descriptions, other than to say that principally this film is about falling in love unexpectedly (between a 40-something film director and a violinist) , and later in life, and of understanding the conflict between passion and intellect, and action and consequences. It's very evocatively filmed in the Pyrenees, and stylistically has a mature grasp on the filmic power of silences and spaces, particularly in the portrayal of the unspoken thought, and the internal struggles of characters we relate to and understand.
Quelques jours en septembre
1) If I sent Unifrance a really nice email, do you think they'd offer to host me in Paris, along with Piers and Noah?
2) This review could be influenced by the fact that the stunningly beautiful Juliette Binoche walked past me within a distance of a mere two feet, thus making my night and possibly my festival.
As for the film, it's quite good. As Sarah indicated, there are similarities to the Third Man, in that the retired spy played by Binoche, a young French woman, and a young American, are all brought together by the father figure (natural to the young woman, step to the young man, thus ensuring that the subsequent romantic dalliance between the two isn't technically incest) who is unseen throughout most of the film. They are pursued through Paris and Venice by a disturbed hitman/agent, played with the usual off-kilter gusto by John Turturro, who appears to want to kill the father. The film marks the days leading up to September 11th, and there are hints that father is calling them all together because he knows what's about to happen in the United States.
To its credit, the film doesn't dwell on conspiracies or try to insert itself too deeply into the tragic events of that day, but instead focuses much of its attention on the relationship between the three characters, their feelings for the absent father, and the way in which they overcome their initial impressions of one another. Geopolitical considerations give way to interpersonal dynamics, amidst the gorgeous backdrop of a sunny Venetian skylines, and the movie finds a nice rhythm as the characters alternately bicker and flirt with one another.
It wasn't surprising to learn that the first time filmmaker is a novelist. The story has the feel and structure of a good paperback thriller. Here I'll disagree with with Sarah's assessment, though. I do think that the writer/director knows how to end it, and ties up all the plot elements quite well. The problem is that in doing so, the story loses some of the authenticity, as characters then have to conform to a standard set of reactions which play themselves out quite conventionally. The plot is resolved to satisfaction, but lacks some of the genuine emotion of earlier scenes.
Still, it's an entertaining film, with some very quirky touches. The Turturro character's frequent calls to his psychoanalyst, and the ringtone on his cellphone, are hilarious, as is his, for some reason, his surprisingly competent French. Binoche's Irene takes all the threats to her life and guns pointed in her face in stride, as if midly amused by the absurdity of it all and yet manages to pull off this unexpected levity with a cool assurance. [Did I mention that she's gorgeous? Even with the bleach blond hair, which I assume is for a role]. And the two young people, played by Sara Forestier and Tom Riley, capture loathing and wide-eyed optimism in with credibility and poise.
My only question: what happens to the turtle?
Radiant City
About 3/4s of the way through, we find out that the family we have been spying on is not really a family but a group of actors. I have to admit, I was a bit disappointed - I KNEW those kids were too funny!! However, that's just a testament to how well written and relevant these family scenes were. As one of the directors put it during the Q&A - "we didn't have the time or the budget to follow a family around for 2 years only to edit all the footage down to the dysfunctional parts we just showed you anyway". I guess this could be considered cheating. It definitely tests the boundaries of how a documentary is typically defined. In the end, I felt that it was an effective tool to illustrate what could have otherwise been a very dry subject matter.
The film's message was sobering - one's journey to own a piece of "paradise" in suburbia is also the road to personal isolation, the repercussion of which is only beginning to be felt in society at large. However, this message was brought to the viewer in an engaging and entertaining way. The 86 minutes this film is listed at flew by. I came away entertained and with much food for thought. I'd have to judge the film a success on that basis alone.
I don't know where you'd be able to watch Radiant City. The movie was co-produced by the National Film Board and the CBC. So, it might turn up on the Passionate Eye at some point. Or, more likely, it'll be made available through the NFB library. If the topic interests you at all I would recommend the movie (actually *we* recommend it - Linda enjoyed it as well).
ADDED BONUS: A kick-ass original soundtrack by Joey Santiago of Pixies fame.
NB: In an ironic twist, of the two directors (Gary Burns, Jim Brown) only Burns was present at the screening. Jim Brown was absent because his employer wouldn't give him time off work. His employer? The CBC. What a world.
Quelques Jours en Septembre
The cast had good chemistry and the dialogue was often clever. John Turturro was a very enjoyable bad guy with a need to consult his therapist after each mistake or murder. My criticism would be that the writter got to a certain point in the script and didn't know how to end it. By a certain point the audience pretty much knows how it is going to play out and sadly no surprises were delivered. Not a perfect movie but I really enjoyed it and would recommend it.
One lingering question is - What happened to the turtle?
Kyle was thrilled that a very blonde Juliette Binoche was at the screening before and after the movie.
Reprise
From the opening montage of quick edits which imagine the future of the two central characters (described in at least one review as an homage to Truffaut’s Jules et Jim but a more recent cultural reference might be those flash, still photo sequences which sketched out the future for some of the characters that the title character would pass while in motion, could almost stand alone as a great short film Tykwer’s Run Lola Run) to a similarly structured, somewhat ambiguous conclusion, this is a film with a lot of passion, energy, humour, and dead-on observations on human relationships.
I hate to ‘over recommend’ a film because it inevitably inflates expectations and leads to disappointment but this is the best one I’ve seen in some time. Sometimes a film just hits every note with precision, capturing what it's like to grow old, struggle with your place in the world and your aspirations to be something interesting to yourself and to the world. If you're guy, that is. If there were any criticisms to make or biases to acknowledge is that this is mostly a guy's film, told from a guy's perspective with keen insight into how guy's tease one another, resist growing old and accepting responsibility, and try to find their place in the world. But I don't think it's a film just for guys; if anything, it provides a glimpse into just how ridiculous and self-important men can be, as well as how difficult it can be to try age with purpose and make real connections with the women in their lives.
Another admission of bias: I'm a huge Joy Division fan and keep thinking back to the opening credit sequence, which shows the characters in the film marching in, and sometimes drunkenly staggering through, an Independence Day parade in Norway (independence from…any Norwegians care to lend a hand with a brief history lesson) while ‘New Dawn Fades’ blares through the soundtrack.
Un Crime
A question.....why oh why do directors feel that I want to see naked Harvey Keitel? Many, many people saw "The Piano." Perhaps prior to "The Piano" directors assumed that we all wondered what exactly Harvey looked like naked. But after we all saw it once did we need to keep seeing it? Harvey is a really good actor. I usually enjoy his performances. I just wish directors would keep him clothed.
So beyond the nakedness, how was the movie? IT SUCKED! The storyline was ridiculous. The acting was not engaging. I should have taken a nap. I was tired and would have benefitted more from the rest than from watching the rest of the film.
The Q and A afterwards was entertaining though. The audience asked the most ridiculous questions I have heard about a movie to date. As an example - One audience member commented on a scene where one a character compares being in love to being in hell. Then the audience member asked if this philosophy was typical the the French.
2:37
I would not have guessed that it was a 1st time director and a cast of 1st time actors. 2:37 was very well done. I feel badly for the director and cast member that attended the screening. There was an incident in the theatre during the last scene of the screening that really took the attention of the audience away from the movie. Someone near the back of the theatre had some sort of medical emergency. The movie credits were abruptly turned off, the lights came up and people were uncomfortable giving the film the applause it deserved. Obviously I don't blame the ill individual and ending the screening was the right thing to do. It just seemed a shame that a screening of a fine film ended on such a bad note.
Paris Je T'aime
Babel
The movie has been getting a lot of press as the next big Brad Pitt movie but it is more accurately an assemble piece. Each of the three storylines were equally absorbing. At 2.5 hours it is quite a long movie but you know I enjoyed it because I have never had to go pee so badly in my life (I swear) but I stayed in my seat until the credits came up.
Kinshasa Palace
Hana
Tuesday, September 12, 2006
The Fountain
I could pull a Stuart here and leave everyone wondering how I really felt about the film but let me plow on despite barely being able to muster the words to bring this sucker to it's knees.
First the good: 1) Clint Mansell's soundtrack with assistance from the Kronos Quartet and Mogwai. 2) Quite beautiful cinematography (but you can get that from the 2 minute trailer that had me all aflutter about this film several months back) 3) At 90 minutes, even though it feels quite often like it's doing your head in, it's mercifully short. May I suggest to Darren Aronofsky that he return to the 2007 film festival to screen a 5 minute version of this hippy dippy piece of tripe.
For those of you that don't know the premise of this film, and I'm not sure I do after having watched it, it revolves around a modern couple Izzy and Tommy, with Izzy (played by Rachel Weisz) slowly dying of a brain tumor and Tommy (played by Hugh Jackman) as a cutting edge research physician working furiously to find a cure for what ails his wife. We also see the same two characters in what appears to be late 15th century Spain replete with a Torquemada like religious fanatic and in a third storyline which one has to assume is set in the future we see only Jackman's character, unamed and floating in space, replete with his own bubble.
This is far removed from the frenetic pace off Aronofsky's first two works, "Pi" and "Requiem for a Dream", the latter's screening of which at the TIFF actually saw an audience member suffer a heart attack. If the first two were seizure inducing quick cut wonders of late 20th century filmmaking then "The Fountain" for me can only be regarded as a throwback to the yoga loving, granola munching, psychadelic tripping days that I never experienced in the 60s. At one point in the last 10 minutes I thought for sure we'd be crossing over from the plangent strings of the Kronos Quartet to the prog-rock noodlings of Edgar Broughton or Hawkwind.
Sadly that never came to pass and as a result the whole po-faced seriousness of the film combined with the ridiculous closing scenes made me want to laugh. Of course being the polite Toronto audience that we are people actually applauded at the end.
In terms of mood the film reminded me very much of 2002's "Solaris" a film I enjoyed immensely and have watched many times over. Unlike "Solaris", "The Fountain" leaves you on the outside looking in. I honestly never cared what end was met by either of the two protagonists in any of their incarnations and even poor old Ellen Burstyn, who was terrific in Requiem, is wasted in her capacity as the hospital's chief.
I'm really not sure what audience this film is intended for. It appears to be big budget, what with the monolithic poster already up at Yonge and Dundas staring down at us in all its false solemnity, but your average Cineplex goer is not going to be interested beyond the good guys vs the Mayan Orcs opening sequence. As for his core audience I imagine they'll be mostly left scratching their heads.
Perhaps Hugh Jackman knew best, as Aronofsky pointed out the man is 15000km away dancing his heart out in something called "The Boy from Oz". Good on yer Hugh, I wish I could've tied me kangaroo down with you sport.
question?
So...Do you need to have read the book and seen the movie to include it on the list?
(If so Im fu....ed)
Tiff Blog List-Making Exercise
Those of us who participate in Kyle's "other" blog like to spend some, arguably way too much, time expressing ourselves and our oh-so-passionate views on art in the form of lists. Like, you know, I believe the fourth greatest punk band of all time is The Damned. You think it's The Gang of Four? Jesus. They are so number six! (yes, we are that High Fidelity-esque).
So, admittedly over a coupla beers, Derek, Kyle and I (OK, I exclusively) decided we should engage in a simple, yet gratifying, film-based list-making undertaking. My question to each of you who have read this far (and from what I can gather the only newcomer may be Daniel) is this "what are the greatest ever films adapted from novels?" And the follow up question (should you choose...) is the not-entirely-unexpected "why?"
I will start with one - Howard Hawks "To Have and Have Not". Why? Based on one of Hemingway's worst books, and very very loosely adapted by the underheralded William Faulkner to echo the spirit and basic plot of Casablanca, it's nearly as good, with fantastic chemistry between Humph....OK I'll, stop there, since this was only meant to be an example (To Have and Have Not is grossly over rated and wouldn't make my list.)
Enjoy your movies!
Little Children
This film follows a number of seemingly disparate characters whose lives intersect in one way or another due to children. There is the wife who feels isolated from both her daughter and her husband, the "cool dad" who takes care of the kids while studying for a bar exam he never wants to pass, the ex-cop who has taken it upon himself to become the unofficial protector of all the children in the neighbourhood, and the recently released sex offender who spent 10 years in jail for exposing himself to a minor. All of their lives become inextricably linked through a series of well acted and completely believable plot twists.
Little Children is first and foremost a character study. Though "character study" is often a euphemism for a slow-moving and boring movie - this film is anything but. I could see pieces of my friends in many of the characters (NO - not the pedophile) and was totally engrossed in the minutiae of their lives. You even manage to empathize with the plight of the sex offender. Couple these excellent character sketches with a complex and thought-provoking plot and you are left with quite a stellar film. I would be surprised if this film didn't generate significant buzz (if it hasn't already).
Though the director called this piece a "satirical drama", it was a very difficult film to watch as he deftly crafted a film with an underlying tension that claws at your belly and leaves you feeling unsettled long after the movie is over. In other words, it was much heavier on the drama than the satire.
My one complaint was the voice-over narrative. If Derek hadn't told me that this film was based on a book, that fact would have become quite clear within the movie's first few narrative-heavy minutes. I found that the voice-over rarely added to the film and instead seemed (at times) to actually cheapen the work and give the film a "Desperate Housewives" feel. However, read this as a very minor complaint in the overall scheme of things.
Loved the movie, glad we picked it - and I didn't even stalk Kate Winslet. Maybe I am growing up.
Un Crime
1) The act of making such a wretched film in the first place
2) The selection of this film for inclusion into the festival where an unsuspecting festival crowd would actually have to watch it
For a litany of more specific crimes, let’s start with the premise. In order to win the affections of her young, widowed neighbour whose wife was murdered by a taxi driver 3 years prior to the events in the film, a beautiful but troubled young woman (Emmanuelle Beart) embarks on a plan to frame a random taxi driver for the neighbour’s wife’s murder, so that the neighbour can have his closure and their romance can commence. Sound a little wonky? Well, to be fair, the neighbour has been obsessed with finding his wife’s killer and has pointedly told the young woman that it can’t happen between them until this happens. Okay, makes sense from his perspective. But why is an attractive young woman willing to go to such lengths, which include seducing the disheveled taxi driver played by Harvey Keitel, for the affections of a gloomy guy, ever clad in a ragged hoody, who lives in a dull, grimy apartment, races and gambles on dogs on the beach, and hasn’t gotten over his wife’s death? I'm saying she could do better.
But we never really get an answer so nothing that follows from this dubious starting point makes much sense. The plot holes are wide enough to drive transport truck through and are too depressingly numerous to catalogue here. I will, however, give some advice to the filmmakers on the subtle use of foreshadowing: having a character demonstrate his prowess with a boomerang prior to his apparent death by drowning is less of a whispered hint as to what comes next as it is a shouted, foregone conclusion.
And for the love of God, would somebody please tell Harvey Keitel to keep his damn clothes on? Whether it’s a decent film like The Piano or the egregiously bad Holy Smoke, Harvey’s unsettling zeal for disrobing on film is not a good thing. I guess he gets some props for continuing to um, put himself out there in every sense of the word but I think at this point, I’d really like him to keep his shirt and his pants on.

Okay, I haven't had a lot of nice things to say about this film so on a positive note, let me end with the blurry photo that I took of Emmanuelle Béart, who was gracious and spirited at the Q&A, even when it was evident that the audience hadn't really dug the flick.
shortbus
3 cheers for yoko ono and others for pitching in with there support..
all in all a very good but not essential film.
the wind that shakes the barley
I too struggled keeping the tearducts unclogged , and while it could be construed that the plot had some manipulative moments ( ala sophies choice) that are guaranteed to bring you down, all in all, I was rivited throughout and few films can do that. The cinematography, acting, direction were all damn near perfect , and finally this film is the oply one to stay with me in a big way....always a telling criteria...essential viewing...
Monday, September 11, 2006
Citizen Duane
While on the surface this film may sound perilously (and needlessly) similar to Alexander Payne's brilliant Election, in most ways it is a much different film. The writing is rarely as sharp, for one thing, though at times Stuart and I were belly laughing - particularly at some of the inspired physical comedy. The tone is also wildly inconsistent, ranging from pure (and too often embarrassingly unfunny) farce, through a more mellow and familiar satire, to something approaching edgy melodrama within the family scenes.
The actors were good, esp. Douglas Smith as Duane, and Alberta Wtason as his mother...but some parts felt under written (Duane's on-again-off-again girlfriend) and some you wished you'd never met (the ridiculous ex-boyfriend gossip columnist of Duane's mom comes to mind, but he's not the only one).
I could claim to be disappointed, but I expected relatively little from this film (despite Mabbot's TIFF success last year), and for its just-frequent-enough genuinely inspired moments, and a solid central performance, I would give Citizen Duane a very mild recommendation.
Sunday, September 10, 2006
Pan's Labyrinth
Just saw my favourite film of the festival so far. Once again back at the Elgin for the screening of Guillermo del Torro's latest film. I saw his film "The Devil's Backbone" at the festival five years ago and also enjoyed 2004's "Hellboy" Del Toro also directed Cronos, Mimic and Blade II so this needless to say is a man who knows how to make you squirm in your comfy Elgin seat and he even warned us of such prior to the screening of the film. He also mentioned that when last at the festival with "The Devil's Backbone" it screened on September 9, 2001 and a day later he was in Los Angeles and we all know what happened the day after that. He mentioned this as a backdrop to some of the themes in his latest film given the rather chaotic state certain parts of the world currently find themselves in.
This film billed in some parts as a fairytale for adults is set in 1944 Spain as the Facists under Franco fight to hold off disparate groups of resistance fighters mounting a losing battle against superior numbers. Sergi Lopez, as Captain Vidal head off the facist stronghold in a countryside setting never identified, plays one of the most cruelly vicious characters I've seen in a film and not in a comic book style manner a la the Nazi pursuer in "Raiders of the Lost Ark". Anyone who has seen Lopez's turns as Harry in 2000's "With a Friend Like Harry" or as the creep of a hotel boss in 2002's "Dirty Pretty Things" already knows how sinister this guy can be in a film.
The two other main leads in the film are Ivana Baquero as 10 year old? Ofelia, the vicious captain's newly adopted daughter, and Maribel Verdu (from Y Tu Mama Tambien) as Mercedes who works in the household employ of the captain but is also the sister of the leader of the local resistance fighters.
There are two storylines here one concerning the Captain's pursuit, and in his words, complete elimination of all those who would resist the new "clean" Spain and the other concerns Ofelia's perhaps imagined journey into the nearby labryinth and the 3 tasks assigned to her by the titular Faun that will see her reclaim her rightful position as princess in her father's long since vanished kingdom.
As hard as it may be to imagine these two intertwined tales work magically together. The terror of the war going on around her is reflected in the equally frightening world that Ofelia finds herself locked in as she attempts to carry out the faun's instructions. Del Toro does horror with a storyline as well as anyone right now and your attention is fixed right to the finish.
I'm not sure I learned much about the Facist reign in Spain (unlike Loach's film already blogged upon here) but it is hardly necessary in understanding Del Toro's themes of lost innocence, the cruelty of battle on all sides and the ultimate foolishness of pride.
Would have loved to write more but have a 9pm screening of "The Last King of Scotland" that I must dash off to.
Saturday, September 09, 2006
The Wind That Shakes the Barley
Knowing director Ken Loach's socialist heart and my celtic brethren's tyrannized existence in Ireland at the hands of the English I came to this film knowing what was coming my way. And I wasn't disappointed. This isn't a great film but it's got a quiet power. It's no "Braveheart" and thus may not appear at your local multiplex anytime soon but as with "The Battle of Algiers" it has a very timely message. There will always be young men (and occasionally women) willing to fight to keep imperial powers off their lands. And it really doesn't matter how these powers spin the justification for their presence in foreign lands at the end of the day the only rule that matters is home rule.
Loach's film focuses on a small contingent of men and a few women, living outside of the major centre of Dublin, struggling with British rule of their country. Only a few years removed from the end of the Great War the Brits still have a well trained fighting fit contingent of soldiers. As we've seen elsewhere in more recent times the option of taking on such an overwhelming military force head-on is no option at all. As such we see the dawning of the Irish Republican Army and the nacsent days of some its more infamous fighting tactics.
As with many of these decades and century long conflicts my knowledge is sadly lacking and this film was certainly educational in that respect although not as engrossing as it could have been, although a scene midway through the film had me in tears. My two major quibbles with this film is that at 2 hours long it's 20-30 minutes longer than it needs to be and could somebody screen this film with subtitles. I've seen some Scottish films (Ken Loach's "Sweet Sixteen" immediately pops to mind) with subtitles and they were a hell of a lot easier to understand than this.
Still an interesting and essential film, especially given the relatively peaceful state Ireland has found over the last 5 years or so. We can only hope that in the near future an Iraqi filmmaker will be able to produce a testament to his country's "independence" under similar circumstances.
Volver
This film opens with a wonderful shot in an ornate cemetery in a small Spanish village that sees only women dusting off the graves of their men who have long since passed because as we are told that is the way life goes in this town. Almodovar then within the first 10 minutes of the film makes short work of the only male character we are introduced to by name, "Paco". It is then down to the ensemble female cast of 6 primary characters to take us through the rest of the rather sketchy but charming story.
One can see why the entire female cast was awarded best actress at Cannes this past spring and also why Alomodovar is back on his game. The man simply knows how to direct women. Penelope Cruz has never looked so stunning or performed so believably with a sly sense of humour and a pervasive humanity that American audiences will never see in the likes of "All the Pretty Horses" or "Sahara". Watching Cruz on the big screen this morning had me thinking that this must have been the way audiences would have been captivated by Sophia Loren in the 60's.
The remainder of the female cast is equally stellar if not quite as stunning to watch and this takes me back to my theory. Gael Garcia Bernal and Javier Bardem are fine actors but they have to my mind given much better performances under the guidance of other directors than they did with Almodovar. Pedro captures women in all their colour, vibrancy and sweet music that they bring to the lives of us rather more pedestrian male creatures and for that I'd like to offer him a great big thanks.
Brand Upon the Brain!
The Elgin was a sublime backdrop for a silent black and white film complete with a 10 piece chamber orchestra comprised of TSO members, 3 sound effects wizards hanging out under the balcony on the right and a rather gargantuan man with an extremely high voice singing several times from up high on the left balcony. As this was all being introduced to us by Guy himself the electricity in the air was more than I can remember for any other Canadian film. Unfortunately the film didn't deliver the goods to match the pre-screening anticipation.
The story itself centred around a guy named Guy and his sister "Sis" who live on this strange remote island with their domineering, omnipresent mother and their workaholic mad scientist like father who spends much of his time extracting youth inducing "nectar" from the motely crew of orphans who have somehow found themselves dropped into this Dickensian scenario. Into this picture drops the renowned children's literary detective brother and sister team of Wendy and Chance Hale which immediately took me back to the good old days of the Famous Five and the Secret Seven.
I wont go any further with the rather zany plot which really works well in a silent setting and given Maddin's previous escapades on screen. Suffice to say there are many laughs, some uncomfortable moments, great performances by the two young female leads Maya Lawson as Sis and Katherine Scharhon as Wendy (and Chance), but at the end of the day not much of a story to tie the whole thing together. At least not one that I was prepared to buy into. And I so bought into the premise of his last feature "The Saddest Music in the World" despite its otherworldy air.
Given that Maddin has stated previously that he based this work on his childhood experiences in Gimli, Manitoba where his parents ran a small summer camp for orphans the man certainly has issues where his mother is concerned. Hopefully he has worked some of them out and if nothing else he provided for all those who attended an experience that was a throwback to the early days of film.
Friday, September 08, 2006
HANA
The story ostensibly centres on Aoki, who hails from a line of samurai and is tasked by his family to avenge his father’s death. In most revenge flicks, it’s only after the hero slaughters his or her way through dozens of bad guys that s/he come to the realization that violence is not the path to redemption. Here the director has chosen to go another direction and pursue an entirely different premise: what if the hero doesn’t think revenge is all that great an idea from the outset?
It’s an intriguing question and the result is that most of the action is dominated not by the hero but by his large cast of supporting characters, who gleefully offer advice and hatch elaborate schemes while enduring their own amusing set of trials and tribulations. The cast is excellent, pitch perfect in that they stop shy of slapstick in scenes that could easily go that route and that they never seem to deviate from the character’s central, humanity. Even the village idiot, who celebrates wildly at the suggestion that a fellow villager’s trip to the outhouse could aid his compost business, comes across as sympathetic instead of simply buffoonish.
If the actions of these characters do start to wear thin at about the 3/4 mark, it’s because there’s very little left for them to do. Once Aoki abandons his revenge, and this happens pretty early on, the narrative itself loses momentum. There's a few scenes that tie up some loose threads and pantomimed sequences that offer a few chuckles but very little to keep audiences engaged emotionally. Beyond a somewhat truculant landlord (who really just wants to collect some back rent from the villagers) and a few child bullies who occupy approximately 15 seconds of screen time and are quickly put off by the pacifistic actions of another child, there’s little tension between any of the characters. Even the father's killer, a man initially marked for death (literally, he's got a red mark on his face), isn't all that menacing, with a wife and two small children and little indication that he's spoiling for a fight.
Though the film is set in the early 18th century, clearly we are meant to see some parallels with the present. The notion of a more respectful, measured response to our perceived enemies of the both in the world at large ("Maybe the President of Iran hugs his kids too...") and our local communities (I'm sure the guy who cut me off is just having a bad day...") is somewhat refreshing given all the usual bluster in movies and the media. The film is pretty upfront in its moralizing: if you let hate consume you, all you are left with is hate. Point taken.
But...can a story really work without at least some real adversity? Without a villain or an act of God?
In some sense, yes. In the case of HANA, the answer lies somewhere between satisfactory and subdued. It’s one of those films that I’d sum up for friend with an “I liked it, but…” or “It was good…” without sounding convincing. Recommended for some, particularly those who have just completed a long yoga session.
Btw…the film’s title….HANA… If I’m not mistaken, this is the name of the caged bird which has the misfortune of being killed by a stray cat midway through the film, but which is at least given a proper and respectful burial by a small child. Not sure what this means or why the film is thus titled but it seems somehow fitting. Perhaps others who have seen this can clarify via comments...
Thursday, September 07, 2006
Are you ready for some f.....ilms?
Here's a clip of the making of the film, courtesy of YouTube:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9polHduyORg
Okay, clearly I'm reaching but there's not much more to write about until the films start.
Guess I could say that I'm glad tonight's film is at the Varsity, which has much more of a festival vibe to it than the Paramount. Deep in the heart of clubland, with its flashing lights sights, cacophony of sounds, and deep-fried donut smells emanating from thefood court concession, the Paramount has always seemed less of a cinema than an adult version of Chuck-e-cheese. While the ample leg room and stadium seating admittedly make for greater viewing pleasure than the constant shifting and weaving of heads necessary to take in a subtitled film at the downstairs cinema at the Cumberland, there's still something to be said for being at the latter venue.
Anyhow, I hope you enjoy your films and that you read and post regularly. Those who haven't been invited to post can either email me for login instructions or make use of the comments section.
Tuesday, September 05, 2006
It's the most wonderful time of the year....
Yesterday was probably the most relaxing Labour Day I've spent in years. Why? Because I got an email from the festival on Saturday letting me know that I got all my film picks; okay one got screwed up but why quibble? With this foreknowledge, I was able to sleep in yesterday, casually make my way over to the box office around noon, and avoid the resubmit line that I spent 4 hours in last year.
Once again, I've reactivated the Film Fest blog, so you have a chance to read about what your friends have seen, and contribute your own opinions on some of the films you've seen.
To get the ball rolling, here are the films I'm seeing this year:
Hana
7 ans
Paris, je t'aime
Beauty in Trouble
Woman on the Beach
Reprise
Un Crime
Quelques jours en Septembre
Il Caimano
L'intouchable
The Banquet
Fay Grim
Looking at my list, which is the usual French and Asian melange, I think the one that has the biggest question mark is Hal Hartley's Fay Grim. His last few films have been, um, terrible, so it will be interesting to see if this one represents a return to form (I stick with him) or a continuation of the downward spiral (I jump off the bandwagon). Parker Posey is consistently great so it's got that going for it, at the very least.
Derek, I know you mentioned that 'The Fountain' was one of the films you were most looking forward to this year. Hopefully, you won't have the same reaction as audiences in Venice. On a brighter note, one of your other picks, 'Volver' was given big love in San Sebastien (a few stories down the page).
At any rate, I do hope you'll have some time to contribute to the blog this year, even if it's only a few bullet-point observations, random nonsequiters with bad grammar (cough, stuart), or a list of what you're planning to see.
Post early, post often, post your list (don't worry about providing links) of films. See you in line.
Sunday, September 18, 2005
The Quiet
Unlike most movies of the week much of this film is shot in dark, muted tones. This is not a happy movie and to its credit their is no cop out ending. Camilla Belle, who played opposite Daniel Day Lewis earlier this year in "The Ballad of Jack and Rose", plays the deaf teenager Dot who comes to stay with her foster family (Donovan, Falco and their daughter played by Elisha Cuthbert) after the death of her parents.
She is the best thing in this film given little to say and having to convey much with a look or abrupt action. Dot finds the transition to life with her new family difficult and needless to say she's not exactly the exalted new kid at the local high school. Quite why a deaf kid is dropped in to the local high school is left unexplained. Maybe this is standard practice these days as we see Dot attending classes with her personal sign language translator. Is this where my taxes go? But I digress.
The focus here is on Dot and her attempts to come to terms with her new life. There are a lot of about-faces in this film which ultimately lead to the demise of one of the main characters and may also try your patience. Not exactly hall of fame material but a good mid-winter, fuck all else to do, rental.
Capote
Which leads me to Capote who despite being fey in the extreme could never be construed as having been a wuss. His acerbic side took care to ensure that his emotional side would never get the better of him. I'm making some rather large suppositions based on a 2 hour biopic but the performance that Philip Seymour Hoffman delivers here most certainly leaves you feeling that for a short time you've seen the man as he really was.
For my money this is a role that Hoffman was born to play. I can't imagine Capote pulling it off with more elan than Hoffman does here. The ridiculous comment by a Now magazine scribe that Hoffman is too statuesque to play the diminutive Capote needs no comment with respect to its irrelevance here.
I checked IMDB and I've now seen Hoffman in 13 films, maybe as many as any other current actor or actress that I can think of, and weak performances are at a bare minimum. This is a guy Oscar has sadly overlooked. Both Hoffman and Jamie Foxx, last year's Oscar winner, are 38 and as I've read from the reviews of "Ray", "Capote" suffers from the same affliction in that this is really a great performance masquerading as a film.
Not that the film is bad by any stretch but the other characters played by the wonderful Catherine Keener, Chris Cooper and Brice Greenwood never get much to sink their teeth in to. It's like the scene in "Aliens" where the queen (pun intended) enters the hive and all the smaller males of the species shrink into the shadows for fear of reprisal.
The film focuses on Capote's final book. A non-fiction account of the gruesome slaying of a Kansas family, the book simultaneously catapults the writer to star status in North America while at the same time derailing his writing career. Much of the film is centred around Capote's complex relationship with one of the two accused, Perry Smith. Capote is fascinated by what motivated this multi-dimensional man to an act of extreme brutality and spends countless hours simply conversing with him in his prison cell.
As the film progresses we see that this is no hagiography. His relationship with Smith reveals much in Capote that is reprehensible. The scenes set in the big city cultural milieu in which Capote most obviously reveled show the side of the man that one cannot help but be attracted to. If you had to come up with a fantasy dinner guest list you could safely start with Capote.
The main flaw in the film for me, other than the peripheral roles played by the aforementioned actors, is that the connection to Perry Smith is never realized. Capote is fascinated by this man. I was less than enthralled. Clifton Collins Jr., who plays Perry Smith, is captivating to watch (his eyes especially) but something is missing in the writing I fear.
Still heartily recommended.
Friday, September 16, 2005
Memories In The Mist
It is the story of a man in his late thirties or early forties who is unhappy in his life. His job at a newspaper is unsatisfying. Because of his unwillingness to stop persuing the story of a corrupt government official, he keeps missing out on the promotions that all of his peers are getting. His wife seems to hate him. He cannot get past a conflict he had with his father as a youngster. The onlt thing that makes him happy are his dog Jill, (not a very Bangali name for a dog) son and daughter.
It was a little slow paced and had a few too many cliches in it to be satisfying. It is not a bad movie or a great movie. I am not sure that I would recommend it......maybe if there was nothing else worth renting at the video store.
Tuesday, September 13, 2005
2 of my 5 movies
"A Travers la Foret"
After the first 10 minutes of "A Travers la Foret" I guessed that this would be a movie that Derek and Kyle would love. The main character spent these first 10 minutes dancing around the room nude. You saw her mostly shot from the waist up but you did get the occasional glimpse of thick pubic hair. She sang, danced and played with her hair, looking pretty all the while.
I changed my mind when the story became silly and dull 11 minutes into the film and continued that way until the end. The actress who sang and danced so prettily in the beginning also became dull looking. It remided me of the Sienfield episode where Jerry dates the "two face." Sometimes she looked cute and other times she looked like a hag. It was distracting.
The end of the movie made no sort of sense and reminded me of a bad movie I saw with my brother and Kyle last year called Hotel. The only difference between the ending of this movie and the ending Hotel was the absence of a scream. Both endings left me feeling cheated and sour. I do not recommend "A Traveers..." I must add that I also do not recommend "Hotel."
"Entre ses Mains"
It is true that I didn't completely buy how the main charater reacted to some of the things that happened to her in the movie. Still I would recommend it to all. I found it very suspenseful, well acted and well directed. I would also be curious to know if others could accept the choices the lead actress makes as realistic.
A Travers La Foret
As a short, this would have actually been alright, as a sweet albeit pretentious exercise that feels like a cross between French New Wave and an episode of Rod Sterling’s Night Gallery. The grieving, often topless Armelle believes she can make contact with her late boyfriend Renaud, and appears to have inadvertinently acquired telekinetic/telehypnotic powers after a failed suicide. Will she reunite with her lost love? Will she learn to love another? Or will she just wander off into the forest to the bemusement of the audiences everywhere?
Introducing the film, the director explained that he wrote the story specifically for the non-actress playing the lead, after seeing her on the street. Also, that he wrote it and made the movie quickly. That about sums it up. It's slight, breezy stuff that I didn't particularly like or dislike with any sort of intensity. The French convey this type of indifference with a slight shrug of the shoulders, shaking of the head, and perhaps a quietly uttered, 'Bof', meaning, 'Whatever'.
Can't really recommend.
Entre Ses Mains
Suitably described in the program guide as a thriller in the tradition of Hitchcock or Chabrol, this is one of those films that relies more on the subtle but progressive revelation of the character's emotions through dialogue and facial expression to add suspense than it does on a complex narrative structure or sudden plot twists.
The story is about a young married woman who may or may not be making friends with the city’s notorious serial killer. Through her encounters with a charming client who flatters her with his quirky, off-beat compliments, we discover that she’s a little bored with her safe if happy home life, and may want to live a little more dangerously…but how much more dangerously? (cheesy italics mine).
I’d seen Anne Fontaine’s previous film “Nathalie” a few years back at the festival and found it a little too low key; here though, the simple, somewhat minimalist way in which the characters are able to slowly reveal a little more about themselves builds to conclusion that is ultimately satisfying.
Sarah doesn’t agree with me completely on this. She liked it but found parts of it unbelievable. I’ll agree that it's a film where the characters often don't make the same choices the audience would make and I’m gonna guess that this will be a sticking point for some. Your ultimate ‘yea’ or ‘nay’ will depend on whether or not you ‘buy’ some of these choices. I was ‘sold’ because I thought that there was never any inconsistency in the way the characters behaved from scene to scene and I continually found it intriguing. Recommend.
Back to Cache--realize I did not comment at all on the political subtext which you’ll probably read about in other reviews or descriptions and I think is very much worth commenting on. More than simply adding an historical reference to the treatment of Algerians by the French in the 1960s or making a statement about the way that many visible minorities are viewed with suspicion or outright hostility in western societies today, Haneke is able to powerfully drive those points home by creating a heartrending portrait of a father and son who continue to be mistreated by people like Daniel Auteuil’s character. The more I think about this film the more I like it. Of course, the more I build it up, the greater than chance of you not liking it or thinking that I've overhyped it so I'll stop here.
Caché
Because I enjoyed Michael Haneke’s ‘Cache’ quite a bit. There’s something so much more powerful for the audience when a director lets the actors and the gravity of the situation he places them in unfold in a careful, deliberate manner. At times funny, disturbing, and tragic, the story is gripping from its extended opening title sequence, holding a single frame on a quiet street scene for several long minutes, to its similarly patient final revealing shot.
Daniel Auteuil and Juliette Binoche are wonderful as a nearing middle-age married couple who become increasingly frustrated with one another as they try to figure how why they’ve been receiving strange postcards and videotapes from an anonymous though seemingly menacing source. They capture, in a very understated but convincing fashion, the way a loving couple can find equal parts comfort and irritation in one another in the face of threats from the outside world.
Sometimes a word like ‘understatement’ in a review can be a code word for ‘boring’ (‘visually stunning’ and ‘hypnotic’ being code words for ‘really fucking boring’) but here it's a compliment. There’s a wonderful scene (not giving anything away here) where Daneil Auteuil’s character visits his aging mother and they engage in pleasantries before she looks him in the eye and asks him to cut the crap and tell her what’s going on. The piercing, knowing look of a mother who always knows when her child is covering up and the evasive, nervous response of the grown up child is probably the most authentic and thus, for some reason, exhilarating exchange I’ve seen on film for some time.
I also don’t recall the last time I’ve been in a theatre and heard several hundred people simultaneously gasp in shock at a sudden, unexpected turn of event on the screen.
So really, the only downside was not really being sure about the story’s conclusion.
The joys of seeing a film in the beautiful Elgin theatre are sometimes overshadowed by the fact that they rarely, if ever, host post-screening Q & As. Had there been one, a simple, “so does this mean that x caused y?” and a confirmation or explanation from the director would have done wonders for me. I’ve since trekked over to IMDB and confirmed what I thought to be the case (or at least been comforted by the fact that others had similar interpretations) but would be interested in comparing notes with some of you all. Highly recommend.
Sunday, September 11, 2005
L'Enfer
It is never less than lovely to watch as the cast is bedecked as only Parisians could possibly be. It is set in either the early spring or late fall so that compelling sadness of seasonal change that Paris pulls off better than any other city also has you in its grasp. I'm setting this up to ensure you that I wanted to love this film as much as I love the pouty lips of Emmanuelle Beart. All the props were in place to guarantee a successful viewer-celluloid relationship.
Suffice to say then that it couldn't possibly live up to its lofty expectations. The story is one of three sisters who have drifted apart in their adult lives as a result of a rather traumatic family incident that shattered their childhood and changed the family dynamic forever. It is set up expertly, revealing the horrific background to their current lives in small but never stultifying steps. The three sisters are realized beautifully by the three lead actresses showing how simple it is to let 5, 10, 15 years pass in our hectic lives without connecting even with those who are realted by blood let alone by chance.
So far so good so what's missing you may ask. I think the French more than any nation have pushed the cinematic boundaries further than one could possibly hope. Perhaps it's just that we don't get the bad French movies on this side of the pond but I think at the very least when you walk in to a French film you know it will be thought provoking. But I think what is too often missing and is my flaw with this feature is the raw emotion. Every moment is just too calculated. If this film was a band it could never be Guided by Voices at the Shoe it would be Coldplay at the ACC.
Nobody in this film, other than the cheating photographer husband has a discernable occupation. The characters spend every moment wondering where they've fucked up, how they can possibly rectify this and attempting to do so. I suppose we'd all like to live our lives tending to our social selves and I suppose the French as much as anyone have a "right" to negate the workingman's existence as perhaps they feel they've covered that ad nauseaum.
Fair enough, it is a movie and it can cover any territory it damn well pleases, but if when it's all played out and I haven't felt anything the characters have conveyed then it's simply a pretentious intellectual exercise in the world of the bourgeoisie and we're simply running to stand still.
I look forward to Tanovic's 3rd film which might just strike a perfect balance.
A Travers la Foret
Battle in Heaven
If you've done any reading of the program book, either on-line or hard copy, you'll know that this is the film that begins and ends with a blow job. Not just any blow job. The young woman performing said fellatio is quite stunning. The lucky recipient on the other hand is a middle-aged everyman with a much more than slightly tumescent belly, with breasts to rival those of Anna Nicole Smith. Not a pretty picture.
The story progresses slowly from this extended opening shot to reveal that our man Marcos is a chauffeur for the aformentioned Ana the daughter of a rich Mexican general. This immediately raises the question of why the apparent role reversal in the opening scene. Rich, young, beautiful woman subservient to the rather unappealing hired help. I'm not sure this is ever answered to our satisfaction or that it needs to be as we're all looking for something to hold on to and sometimes those that are closest and know us best, Marcos having practically raised Ana since she was a baby qualifies here, are those to whom our bonds are tightest.
As the story unveils we come to see that Marcos is someone merely putting in his time. Life holds very little hope of emotional payoff for him. His best years are already behind him and even sex, whether with his similarly large girthed wife or the buxom Ana, seems to hold little in the way of pleasure. Much of the first hour of the movie is scored with a myriad of everyday sounds noting the relentless passage of time. As this inexorable forward movement takes place many everyday occurrences are shown in an entirely unexpected and stark new light.
That this movie takes the commonplace and presents it in a unique perspective is its major strength. Its many beautiful while brutal images of Mexico City also imbue it with much of its power. I'm fairly certain there is much in this movie that went over my head where the politics of Mexico are concerned. Divisions along sexual, religious and class lines play a huge part here and despite their proximity our southern neighbor plus one is one that I am shamefully unequipped to discuss with any semblance of knowledge.
"Y tu Mama Tambien" may have titillated you, I would say let this film take you deeper into the complex world that is modern day Mexico.
Douches Froides
My first day at the festival encompassed 3 films with copious nudity both male and female with varying degrees of success at creating an interesting story around the naughty bits as Monty Python might say.
Given the wobbly bits on display needless to say my first film was a French effort, god bless them, with this particular film focusing on a trio of high school age teens doing what high schoolers everywhere do best: attempting figure out what the fuck am I doing here. Can't say I felt particularly despondent at their plight given the uniformly beautiful faces and physiques shared by the two young male and one female lead. Their shared shower experience in the high school gym also didn't evoke too many knowing nods. And has anyone else noticed how easy it is to run around naked after hours in the curves and crevices of the local high school?
Essentially this film's focus is the young judoka black belt Mickael who after pulling a prank in the shower knocks one of his slighter teammates out of the upcoming "European championship" decides that the noble thing to do would be lose 7 kilos to drop down a weight class and take his forsaken teammates place. As this backdrop to the film proceeds apace Mickael does his best to deal with his working class family's day to day existence and the arrival on the scene of a decidedly more upwardly mobile teammate who becomes both a friend and a rival for his girlfriend's affections.
The problem for me with most feature films that have the sporting life as a central focus is that there seem to be only two resolutions. a) the central character is a hero with all the glory that implies (think most American films of this ilk) or b) catastrophe at the most crucial moment (guess which category this one falls into). Having participated in organized sport for most of my educational life the truth is much more mundane and I suppose that's why we have no stories of characters or teams finishing in 5th place. Where's the drama in that? Unfortunately then with this type of film it's telegraphed fairly early which side of the dramatic fence our story will fall.
The best moments in this film for me were those that focused on Mickael's family. His dad is a heavy drinking taxi driver and his mum a night shift cleaning lady in her son's school. Both characters are incredibly real, as any in a Mike Leigh film, and have a melancholy sense of humour that strikes home most fully near the end of the film when the French hydro "auditor" informs them that they have come in under their annual kwh quota of 6000 by registering 5999 and the family promptly goes apeshit revelling in their new found freedom to abuse the state's energy supply. Anyone living this past summer in Dalton McGuinty's Ontario cannot help but join in their glee.
Friday, September 09, 2005
The President's Last Bang
In what could have been a sombre, brooding series of set pieces chronicling the last days and violent demise of South Korea’s President/Dictator, or a measured study of conflicted men grappling with the issue of employing sinister means to a noble end, director Im Sang-Soo instead opts for a fast-paced comic portrait of men in power behaving badly.
I’m not familiar with the history of this event and I’m sure that far more comprehensive and reverent interpretations exist. But I can’t imagine a version as compelling or, oddly enough, realistic, given the way he captures what in all probability is the driving force behind most political and historical events: supreme self-interest.
Are the assassins acting out of a desire to see democracy flourish? Do they have designs on absolute power of their own? Or are they simply tired of kowtowing to their overbearing, boorish superiors? The implication is that political-military power structures are doomed to self-destruction because their inherent reliance on conformity breeds resentment and hostility. I think it's a pretty germane statement for our times; in the post-screening Q&A, Sang-Soo was keen to point out a possible link between the ignoble cretins in his film to the ahem, less than stellar administration to our south.
Credit to the film’s success, though, goes to the cast, whose alternate takes on macho bravado, craven sycophancy, and exasperated confusion communicate the absurdity of their situation without or resorting to broad farce or slapstick. That the pacing is standard potboiler thriller and the plot's resolution is a foregone conclusion fairly early on in no way detracts from the film as a whole. Very good and recommend.
Though I’ve been mocked in the past for my ostensible fixation on Asian films at recent fests, I’ve gotta say, they offer the most bang for the buck. Three of the most daring and thought-provoking films I saw last year—3 Iron, Spider Forest, and Old Boy--were all from South Korea and if TPLB is any indication, this trend will continue. I’m looking forward to Sympathy for Lady Vengeance (and may rush for Duelist, one of my original picks that fell victim to Box 33).
BTW...on the heels of my breakout performance on Global TV last night, all future correspondence will be handled by my coterie of handlers. Anyone wanting to get in on the ground floor of an entourage-ship are encouraged to apply.
Thursday, September 08, 2005
My Stripped Down Itinerary
A rather pared down list from last year's 16 tickets and I'm seriously jonesing for more films. I looked at the online ordering page today and was going to pick up a ticket for A Little Trip to Heaven , which Sarah is seeing on the final Saturday. The problem, beyond the somewhat pricy $19.50 per ticket price, is the $5.59 handling fee they want to tack onto the cost of the ticket. Who's handling the ticket? For $5.59 it had better be someone like Natalie Portman.
Incidentally, Natalie is supposed to be here next week and I may rush for that film, which I had selected but didn't get because I was in a bad box this year. I could offer lame excuses about Amos Gitai being an important director but you'd see right through me. You may begin slagging me at any time.
First film is tonight and I look forward to posting my brilliant analysis here this morning. I'm sure you are all equally looking forward to reading it. Would love to read about what you all saw, particularly if you hated what you saw; those always tend to be the most fun to read.
Above all, happy festival!
Tuesday, August 09, 2005
Train Wreck written all over it
"Mary: Abel Ferrara's Italian-American film about a movie director (Matthew Modine) who casts himself as Jesus Christ. Juliette Binoche plays the actress playing Mary Magdalene. Also features Forest Whitaker and Heather Graham."